An examination of ethical standpoints: Organ transplants within the framework of islamic law
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35335/a97nby94Keywords:
Cultural Sensitivity, Ethical Perspectives, Healthcare Practices, Islamic Ethics, Organ TransplantationAbstract
This research to explores the ethical perspectives on organ transplantation within Islamic jurisprudence, aiming to inform culturally sensitive and ethically sound healthcare practices. The review synthesizes findings from a range of scholarly sources to examine the diverse viewpoints among Islamic scholars regarding the permissibility and ethical implications of organ transplantation. Key themes include debates on issues such as brain death, organ trafficking, and the definition of death in Islamic law, as well as the influence of cultural, social, and geopolitical factors on Islamic perspectives. Insights gained highlight the importance of integrating Islamic ethics into medical education and healthcare delivery systems to promote culturally competent care. Recommendations for future research emphasize the need for comparative studies, ethnographic research, and interventions to enhance healthcare providers' cultural competence and religious literacy. By addressing these research directions, scholars can contribute to more inclusive and equitable healthcare practices that respect diverse religious and cultural beliefs while upholding ethical principles and promoting patient-centered care.
Research Highlights:
- Diverse Perspectives: The systematic literature review reveals a spectrum of viewpoints among Islamic scholars regarding the permissibility and ethical implications of organ transplantation. Debates encompass issues such as brain death, organ trafficking, and the definition of death in Islamic law, reflecting the complexity of ethical considerations within the Islamic tradition.
- Cultural Influences: Cultural, social, and geopolitical factors significantly shape Islamic perspectives on organ transplantation, influencing attitudes and practices within Muslim communities worldwide. Understanding these influences is essential for promoting culturally sensitive healthcare practices and addressing the diverse needs of Muslim patients.
- Integration of Ethics: The review underscores the importance of integrating Islamic ethics into medical education and healthcare delivery systems to ensure culturally competent and ethically sound care. Recommendations include curriculum development, interdisciplinary collaboration, and community engagement to enhance healthcare providers' understanding of Islamic principles and values.
References
Abu-Hajiar, R. (2018). Biomedical ethics in cultural diversity: the principle of autonomy in Islamic culture. Doshisha University.
Abu-Shamsieh, K. (2020). End of Life Care and Islamic Practical Theology: A Case Study: The Dying Experience of Prophet Muhammad. Graduate Theological Union.
Ahmed, K., & Hassan, L. (2023). Ethics and Morality: A Comparative Study across Religious Belief Systems. Al-Awan, 1(01), 31–41.
Akrami, F., Karimi, A., Abbasi, M., & Shahrivari, A. (2018). Adapting the principles of biomedical ethics to Islamic principles and values in the context of public health policy. Journal for the Study of Religions and Ideologies, 17(49), 46–59.
Alfahmi, M. Z. (2022). Justification for requiring disclosure of diagnoses and prognoses to dying patients in Saudi medical settings: a maqasid Al-Shariah-based Islamic bioethics approach. BMC Medical Ethics, 23(1), 72.
Ali, J. A. (2021). Islamic perspectives on organ transplantation: a continuous debate. Religions, 12(8), 576.
Ali, M., & Maravia, U. (2020). Seven faces of a fatwa: organ transplantation and Islam. Religions, 11(2), 99.
Alwani, Z. (2019). Transformational Teaching: Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) as a Teacher and Murabbī. Journal of Islamic Faith and Practice, 2(1), 91–119.
Atkinson, C. (2015). Islamic values and nursing practice in Kuwait. Journal of Holistic Nursing, 33(3), 195–204.
AZIZ, A., HAIDER, W. A. L. I., BAIG, H., NAZ, S., ISLAM, A., BASHEER, G., & SAJJAD, K. (2023). POST-MORTEM IN ISLAMIC JURISPRUDENCE: EXAMINING PERSPECTIVES, PRINCIPLES, AND PRACTICES. Russian Law Journal, 11(4).
Bassiouni, M. C., & Badr, G. M. (2001). The Shari’ah: Sources, interpretation, and rule-making. UCLA J. Islamic & Near EL, 1, 135.
Beard, B. H. (1969). Fear of death and fear of life: The dilemma in chronic renal failure, hemodialysis, and kidney transplantation. Archives of General Psychiatry, 21(3), 373–380.
Bello, A. K., Alrukhaimi, M., Ashuntantang, G. E., Basnet, S., Rotter, R. C., Douthat, W. G., Kazancioglu, R., Köttgen, A., Nangaku, M., & Powe, N. R. (2017). Complications of chronic kidney disease: current state, knowledge gaps, and strategy for action. Kidney International Supplements, 7(2), 122–129.
Bhopal, R. S. (2007). Ethnicity, race, and health in multicultural societies: foundations for better epidemiology, public health, and health care. Oxford University Press.
Booth, A. (2016). Searching for qualitative research for inclusion in systematic reviews: a structured methodological review. Systematic Reviews, 5, 1–23.
Bramer, W. M., De Jonge, G. B., Rethlefsen, M. L., Mast, F., & Kleijnen, J. (2018). A systematic approach to searching: an efficient and complete method to develop literature searches. Journal of the Medical Library Association: JMLA, 106(4), 531.
Choong, K. A. (2015). Islam and palliative care. Global Bioethics, 26(1), 28–42.
Cok, G. (2024). Muhammad A. Ali, Omer Bajwa, Sondos Kholaki, and Jaye Starr, eds. Mantle of Mercy: Islamic Chaplaincy in North America. Pennsylvania: Templeton Press, 2022. Journal of Islamic Faith and Practice, 5(1), 154–159.
Cooper, C., Booth, A., Britten, N., & Garside, R. (2017). A comparison of results of empirical studies of supplementary search techniques and recommendations in review methodology handbooks: a methodological review. Systematic Reviews, 6, 1–16.
Crutchley, M. (2022). The gift of life: an existential phenomenological exploration of receiving a lifesaving organ transplant and how this affects life subsequently.
Currier, J. M., Fox, J., Vieten, C., Pearce, M., & Oxhandler, H. K. (2023). Enhancing competencies for the ethical integration of religion and spirituality in psychological services. Psychological Services, 20(1), 40.
Dąbrowska-Bender, M., Kozaczuk, A., Pączek, L., Milkiewicz, P., Słoniewski, R., & Staniszewska, A. (2018). Patient quality of life after liver transplantation in terms of emotional problems and the impact of sociodemographic factors. Transplantation Proceedings, 50(7), 2031–2038.
DeLuca, J. B., Mullins, M. M., Lyles, C. M., Crepaz, N., Kay, L., & Thadiparthi, S. (2008). Developing a comprehensive search strategy for evidence based systematic reviews.
Deshmukh, C. D., & Baheti, A. M. (2020). Need, process and importance of organ transplantation. Asian Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology, 6(2), 126–131.
Dickersin, K., Scherer, R., & Lefebvre, C. (1994). Systematic reviews: identifying relevant studies for systematic reviews. Bmj, 309(6964), 1286–1291.
Dodhiya, M. R., & Ghanbari, M. (2022). Islamic Model of Peaceful Coexistence amongst Human Beings. International Multidisciplinary Journal of Pure Life, 9(31), 93–144.
Dolgin, J., & Shepherd, L. L. (2018). Bioethics and the Law. Aspen Publishing.
Dunn, M. A., Rogal, S. S., Duarte‐Rojo, A., & Lai, J. C. (2020). Physical function, physical activity, and quality of life after liver transplantation. Liver Transplantation, 26(5), 702–708.
Elzamzamy, K., & Keshavarzi, H. (2019). Navigating ethical dilemmas in mental health practice between professional ethics and Islamic values. Journal of Islamic Faith and Practice, 2(1), 40–71.
Evans, R. W. (2019). A catastrophic disease perspective on organ transplantation. In Medicine And Society (pp. 61–95). Routledge.
Fargin, M. (2022). Permissibility of organ donation in Islam-The opinion of lay Muslims in Britain. University of Leeds.
Garcia, M. B., Garcia, P. S., Maaliw, R. R., Lagrazon, P. G. G., Arif, Y. M., Ofosu-Ampong, K., Yousef, A. M. F., & Vaithilingam, C. A. (2024). Technoethical Considerations for Advancing Health Literacy and Medical Practice: A Posthumanist Framework in the Age of Healthcare 5.0. In Emerging Technologies for Health Literacy and Medical Practice (pp. 1–19). IGI Global.
Garwood-Gowers, A. (2019). Living donor organ transplantation: key legal and ethical issues. Routledge.
Ghaffar, A., Qasim, T., & Haider, W. A. (2024). The Compassionate Diplomat: Prophet Muhammad’s (Peace Be Upon Him) Approach to Interfaith Relations. Al-ISRA, 2(02), 23–48.
Ghaly, M. (2012). Religio-ethical discussions on organ donation among Muslims in Europe: an example of transnational Islamic bioethics. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 15, 207–220.
Golmakani, M. M., Niknam, M. H., & Hedayat, K. M. (2005). Transplantation ethics from the Islamic point of view. Med Sci Monit, 11(4), 105–109.
Gupta, S., Rajiah, P., Middlebrooks, E. H., Baruah, D., Carter, B. W., Burton, K. R., Chatterjee, A. R., & Miller, M. M. (2018). Systematic review of the literature: best practices. Academic Radiology, 25(11), 1481–1490.
Gusenbauer, M., & Haddaway, N. R. (2020). Which academic search systems are suitable for systematic reviews or meta‐analyses? Evaluating retrieval qualities of Google Scholar, PubMed, and 26 other resources. Research Synthesis Methods, 11(2), 181–217.
Hall, M. A., Bobinski, M. A., Orentlicher, D., Cohen, I. G., Bagley, N., & Sawicki, N. N. (2024). Health care law and ethics. Aspen Publishing.
Hammami, M. M., Al-Gaai, E. A., Al-Jawarneh, Y., Amer, H., Hammami, M. B., Eissa, A., & Qadire, M. Al. (2014). Patients’ perceived purpose of clinical informed consent: Mill’s individual autonomy model is preferred. BMC Medical Ethics, 15, 1–12.
Hasan, S. (2024). Philanthropy and social justice in Islam: Principles, prospects, and practices. Prospects, and Practices (January 30, 2024).
Hasib, M. (2021). The Moral Ethos of Islam and the West: A Comparative Study. Al Haqeeqah, 1(1), 24–32.
Hasnain, R., Shaikh, L. C., & Shanawani, H. (2008). Disability and the Muslim perspective: An introduction for rehabilitation and health care providers.
Hattab, A. S. (2021). Healthcare Ethics: From Medical Paternalism to Patient Autonomy. In Handbook of Healthcare in the Arab World (pp. 1603–1619). Springer.
Hauerwaas, A., & Weisenfeld, U. (2020). The impact of systemic innovations for transforming transplant systems. Lessons learned from the German lung transplantation system. A qualitative study. Health Systems, 9(1), 76–93.
Huang, Y., Schuehle, J., Porter, A. L., & Youtie, J. (2015). A systematic method to create search strategies for emerging technologies based on the Web of Science: illustrated for ‘Big Data.’ Scientometrics, 105, 2005–2022.
Jamal, A. Z. B. H. A. (2019). Muslim Religious Scholars on the Commodification of Human Body and its Dignity in the Age of Biomedical Revolution. Hamad Bin Khalifa University (Qatar).
Javadli, G. K. (2024). Islam and bioethics: Moral and theological substances in the basic sources of Islam. Universidad y Sociedad, 16(1), 120–125.
Kader, H. (2021). Human well-being, morality and the economy: an Islamic perspective. Islamic Economic Studies, 28(2), 102–123.
Keshavarzi, H., Khan, F., Ali, B., & Awaad, R. (2020). Applying Islamic principles to clinical mental health care: Introducing traditional Islamically integrated psychotherapy. Routledge.
Kiani, M., Abbasi, M., Ahmadi, M., & Salehi, B. (2018). Organ transplantation in Iran; current state and challenges with a view on ethical consideration. Journal of Clinical Medicine, 7(3), 45.
Koch, T. (2020). 8. Ethics and Transplantation. Ethics in Everyday Places.
Koenig, H. G., & Al Shohaib, S. (2014). Health and well-being in Islamic societies. Springer.
Krutzinna, J., Taddeo, M., & Floridi, L. (2019). Enabling posthumous medical data donation: an appeal for the ethical utilisation of personal health data. Science and Engineering Ethics, 25(5), 1357–1387.
Kupiec-Weglinski, J. W. (2022). Grand challenges in organ transplantation. Frontiers in Transplantation, 1, 897679.
Leong, H. S., Butler, K. S., Brinker, C. J., Azzawi, M., Conlan, S., Dufès, C., Owen, A., Rannard, S., Scott, C., & Chen, C. (2019). On the issue of transparency and reproducibility in nanomedicine. Nature Nanotechnology, 14(7), 629–635.
Lepoittevin, M., Giraud, S., Kerforne, T., Barrou, B., Badet, L., Bucur, P., Salamé, E., Goumard, C., Savier, E., & Branchereau, J. (2022). Preservation of organs to be transplanted: An essential step in the transplant process. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 23(9), 4989.
Liverman, C. T., Domnitz, S., & Childress, J. F. (2018). Opportunities for organ donor intervention research: Saving lives by improving the quality and quantity of organs for transplantation. National Academies Press.
Malek, M. M., Abdul Rahman, N. N., Hasan, M. S., & Haji Abdullah, L. (2018). Islamic considerations on the application of patient’s autonomy in end-of-life decision. Journal of Religion and Health, 57, 1524–1537.
Manzano, A. (2023). Global Health Disparities and Trafficking of Human Beings for the Purpose of Organ Removal. In Human Trafficking: A Global Health Emergency: Perspectives from Nursing, Criminal Justice, and the Social Sciences (pp. 205–218). Springer.
Mathur, S., Janaudis‐Ferreira, T., Hemphill, J., Cafazzo, J. A., Hart, D., Holdsworth, S., Lovas, M., & Wickerson, L. (2021). User‐centered design features for digital health applications to support physical activity behaviors in solid organ transplant recipients: A qualitative study. Clinical Transplantation, 35(12), e14472.
McLean, K. A., Drake, T. M., Sgro, A., Camilleri‐Brennan, J., Knight, S. R., Ots, R., Adair, A., Wigmore, S. J., & Harrison, E. M. (2019). The effect of liver transplantation on patient‐centred outcomes: a propensity‐score matched analysis. Transplant International, 32(8), 808–819.
Mohamed Shaffril, H. A., Samsuddin, S. F., & Abu Samah, A. (2021). The ABC of systematic literature review: the basic methodological guidance for beginners. Quality & Quantity, 55, 1319–1346.
Mohammed, J. A. (2007). Corporate social responsibility in Islam. Auckland University of Technology.
Molina-Mula, J., & Gallo-Estrada, J. (2020). Impact of nurse-patient relationship on quality of care and patient autonomy in decision-making. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(3), 835.
Muhamad, A.-A. Bin. (1987). Zakat and rural development in Malaysia: an ethical analysis of the concepts of growth and redistribution of income and wealth in Islam and their practices in a contemporary Muslim society. Temple University.
Muhammed, M. K., & Ali, M. M. (2017). The shariah and law: An analysis. International Journal of Law, Government and Communication (IJLGC), 2(5).
Mustafa, Y. (2014). Islam and the four principles of medical ethics. Journal of Medical Ethics, 40(7), 479–483.
Nouman, M., Siddiqi, M. F., Ullah, K., & Jan, S. (2021). Nexus between higher ethical objectives (Maqasid Al Shari’ah) and participatory finance. Qualitative Research in Financial Markets, 13(2), 226–251.
Padela, A. I., Ali, M., & Yusuf, A. (2021). Aligning medical and Muslim morality: an Islamic bioethical approach to applying and rationing life sustaining ventilators in the COVID-19 pandemic era. Journal of Islamic Ethics, 7(1–2), 129–164.
Padela, A. I., & Auda, J. (2020). The moral status of organ donation and transplantation within Islamic law: the Fiqh Council of North America’s position. Transplantation Direct, 6(3), e536.
Padela, A. I., & Duivenbode, R. (2018). The ethics of organ donation, donation after circulatory determination of death, and xenotransplantation from an Islamic perspective. Xenotransplantation, 25(3), 1–12.
Padela, A. I., & Zaidi, D. (2018). The Islamic tradition and health inequities: A preliminary conceptual model based on a systematic literature review of Muslim health-care disparities. Avicenna Journal of Medicine, 8(01), 1–13.
Pellegrino, E. D., & Thomasma, D. C. (1997). Helping and healing: Religious commitment in health care. Georgetown University Press.
Pressman, S. M., Borna, S., Gomez-Cabello, C. A., Haider, S. A., Haider, C., & Forte, A. J. (2024). AI and Ethics: A Systematic Review of the Ethical Considerations of Large Language Model Use in Surgery Research. Healthcare, 12(8), 825.
Purkon, A. (2022). Rethinking of contemporary Islamic law methodology: Critical study of Muhammad Shahrūr’s thinking on Islamic law sources. HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies, 78(4).
Sajber, K., & Khaleefah, S. (2024). Culturally competent respect for the autonomy of Muslim patients: fostering patient agency by respecting justice. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 45(2), 133–149.
Salahi, A. (2009). COMPASSION: THE MOST PROMINENT CHARACTERISTIC OF MUHAMMAD (PEACE BE ON HIM). Insights (20724586), 2.
Samori, Z., & Badran, I. (2018). Somatic gene therapy: Ethical consideration and Islamic Fiqhi perspective. Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 13(12), 4353-43ól.
Serour, G. I. (2013). Ethical issues in human reproduction: Islamic perspectives. Gynecological Endocrinology, 29(11), 949–952.
Shabana, A. (2022). Limits to Personal Autonomy in Islamic Bioethical Deliberations on End-of-Life Issues in Light of the Debate on Euthanasia. In End-of-Life Care, Dying and Death in the Islamic Moral Tradition (pp. 238–281). Brill.
Stokke, O. M. B. (2014). The Construction of Modern Islamic Authority: Analyzing the medical ethics of the Islamic Organization for Medical Sciences.
Tanveer, Y., Arif, A., Tsenteradze, T., Anika, N. N., Bakht, D., Masood, Q. F., Affaf, M., Batool, W., Yadav, I., & Gasim, R. W. (2023). Revolutionizing Heart Transplantation: A Multidisciplinary Approach to Xenotransplantation, Immunosuppression, Regenerative Medicine, Artificial Intelligence, and Economic Sustainability. Cureus, 15(9).
Terry Sharrer, G. (2022). Transplantation Medicine: An Historical Perspective. Molecular Frontiers Journal, 6(01n02), 46–62.
Thalib, P. (2018). Distinction of characteristics sharia and fiqh on islamic law. Yuridika, 33(3), 439–452.
Toumi, S., & Su, Z. (2023). Islamic values and human resources management: A qualitative study of grocery stores in the Quebec province. International Journal of Cross Cultural Management, 23(1), 79–112.
Vanholder, R., Domínguez-Gil, B., Busic, M., Cortez-Pinto, H., Craig, J. C., Jager, K. J., Mahillo, B., Stel, V. S., Valentin, M. O., & Zoccali, C. (2021). Organ donation and transplantation: a multi-stakeholder call to action. Nature Reviews Nephrology, 17(8), 554–568.
Wade, J. (2023). A Historical Review of Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation: Developmental Advancements Then and Now. Senior Honors Theses.
Wadström, J., Ericzon, B.-G., Halloran, P. F., Bechstein, W. O., Opelz, G., Serón, D., Grinyó, J., Loupy, A., Kuypers, D., & Mariat, C. (2017). Advancing transplantation: new questions, new possibilities in kidney and liver transplantation. Transplantation, 101(2), S1–S42.
Weimar, W., Bos, M. A., & Busschbach, J. J. V. (2008). Organ transplantation: Ethical, legal and psychosocial aspects. Pabst.
Wiltshire, G., Clarke, N. J., Phoenix, C., & Bescoby, C. (2021). Organ transplant recipients’ experiences of physical activity: Health, self-care, and transliminality. Qualitative Health Research, 31(2), 385–398.
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Sharrer Mariat, Abdul Malek Hasan, Mustafa Bin Auda, Sgro Shaffril (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
